![](https://techestate.io/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/fight-cash.webp)
At the bottom of the pyramid, every fintech’s major competitor is cash.
If you need confirmation, look at what is happening in Nigeria now. In November last year, the Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria, Godwin Emefiele, announced a new redesigned currency to combat counterfeiting and cash hoarding¹.
Since the announcement in November 2022, the CBN has been tasked with replacing old notes with new ones. But, the new notes are in very short supply, with the CBN’s actions effectively reducing the amount of cash in circulation in an economy heavily dependent on it. Warren Buffett famously said, “Only when the tide goes out do you learn who has been swimming naked.” As the CBN drains the ocean of cash that has anchored our financial pyramid, it’s exposing Nigerians to the frailties of the banking and fintech ecosystem it helped create. By mid-February, the government recognised the position it had placed itself in, extending the use of the old N200 notes until April.
All payment channels — cash included — solve the same core problems for customers: buy stuff, get paid, get help, and send help. But there are trade-offs between these channels, with cash holding some powerful advantages over cards and digital transfers, and vice versa.
Is Africa doing product “wrong”?
A major reason why cash keeps winning at the “bottom of the pyramid”, with apps the champions at the top and the middle, is that its relative advantages outweigh its disadvantages in situations where both the transaction amounts and the customer’s total savings are small.
- A N60 charge is negligible for a N100,000 transfer but is unthinkable on a N200 payment for a labourer’s lunch. That’s why people don’t appreciate fintech founders telling them to “just make transfers”.
- Having your life savings safely in a bank vault (or server, really) is only an appealing feature for someone whose life savings can’t fit in their pocket.
- The lower the amount in the bank account, the less sense it makes to go to the bank because of the costs. And that cost isn’t only measured in money. Lower-income customers can’t afford to spend much time away from productive work on errands like bank runs. The combination of ATM cards and ubiquitous POS agents was beginning to solve this by ensuring that access to one’s account was just a block away. But now, cash scarcity has forced half the POS agents nationwide to shut down, ironically making the banking system even less attractive.
- Cash is the greatest beneficiary of network effects ever. Everyone is a cash user. We all accept it. No one is unfamiliar with the concept or suspicious of it. For the financially vulnerable, the safety this status brings outweighs almost every other drawback of cash. Again, POS agent networks were beginning to erode this advantage by making cash more accessible from the banking system. Yet, their business model relies on cash to exist. Nor can POS agent networks help the banking system drain currency from Nigeria’s cash ocean. Their existence is based on being a middleman between those wanting cash and those supplying it.
- Killer UX/UI. In places like Nigeria, income is also strongly correlated with literacy and digital comfort. Everyone knows how to use cash, yet many of these people don’t know how to use apps, are too intimidated to learn and don’t trust the technology underpinning the banking system. This is the starting line. It’s taken almost a decade for wider society to become comfortable with the 4-digit ATM card pin, with the success of POS agents built on that comfort. The work to do the same with apps and USSD is still ongoing.
These are all tangible reasons why, unless we take some radical leap forward in fintech products that target the bottom of the pyramid in Nigeria, cash will remain king.
Maybe nobody told the CBN.
Necessity does not always drive adoption
Many fintech builders think the cash shortage in Nigeria will drive up the adoption of apps and services connected to the digitisation of cash. I don’t share that optimism.
Yes, we’ve seen an increase in electronic transactions, but the increased traffic is also knocking out apps whose backend does not match their customer promise. Card payments are failing. Nigeria’s cash crunch has tested the country’s digital payments infrastructure, and the results are not pretty. This is making more and more vendors refuse to take anything but cash.
Granted, we can assume this was simply because banks and fintechs were unprepared for the surge. Maybe in the coming months, they’ll roll out extra capacity, and failure rates will go back down from “almost all the time” to “very frequent”.
But, even if capacity improves, it can’t solve bad commercial fundamentals. If the transaction fee percentage is too high to be competitive, the business is dead in the water. People won’t eat a loss. It will force them to close their businesses, stop buying some things or go elsewhere.
Meanwhile, cash has no transaction fees. You can hold it, smell it, see it, count it and hide it. It is “online” for as long as you have it, and it’s yours.
Recognising this problem, Sterling Bank has temporarily waived transaction charges on all their channels. It’s a great move to keep businesses going during this cash shock, but evidence that a purely cashless Nigeria still doesn’t make business sense.
If the banks can’t get paid for cashless transactions at the pyramid’s bottom, their current models don’t work, and new business models are needed. Forced cashlessness won’t change that.
So what will? Instead of suggesting solutions in this article, I’ll draw from my career experience in Product and leave you with my summary of the problems facing the bottom of the pyramid in Nigeria.
- Customers at the bottom won’t adopt cashless electronic systems because of prohibitive transaction fees and physical inconvenience.
- Fintechs and banks can’t sustainably/profitably provide cashless options to customers at the bottom because their current business models rely on flat transaction fees, their products aren’t intuitive at certain education levels, and network effects are poor.
I believe the next fintech unicorns will unlock the value at the bottom of the pyramid by solving these problems.
Until then, attempts to force cashlessness through restrictions and policies will fail, but only after causing serious damage to the economy, businesses, and people’s lives.
Source: Andrew Obuoforibo
[1] Emefiele blames cash hoarding for Nigeria’s soaring inflation. He said in January that out of 3.23 Trillion Naira in circulation in October 2022, only 500 Billion (less than 16%) was within the banking industry. His critics point out that the remaining 2.7 Trillion in circulation still makes up only 6% of the total money supply of 52.14 Trillion Naira. A drop in the ocean that they say can’t be the major inflation driver. For that, they point to the CBN issuing over 20 Trillion to lend to the Government.
89 replies on “You can’t fight cash”
buying prescription drugs in mexico: Medicines Mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies
cheap ed meds online: Cheapest online ED treatment – online ed prescription
best online pharmacies in mexico: Purple pharmacy online ordering – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
order ed pills online: Best ED pills non prescription – best online ed medication
buy generic deflazacort over the counter – buy alphagan generic how to get brimonidine without a prescription
besivance for sale online – order generic sildamax buy sildamax no prescription
https://lisinopril.guru/# lisinopril 25
cytotec abortion pill: Misoprostol price in pharmacy – cytotec online
lasix 100 mg lasix tablet lasix side effects
cytotec online http://tamoxifen.bid/# tamoxifen benefits
furosemide 100 mg
tamoxifen cyp2d6: how does tamoxifen work – tamoxifen bone density
https://cytotec.pro/# cytotec online
lasix online buy furosemide online generic lasix
buy misoprostol over the counter https://tamoxifen.bid/# natural alternatives to tamoxifen
lasix 40mg
lasix side effects: cheap lasix – buy furosemide online
Thank you very much for sharing, I learned a lot from your article. Very cool. Thanks.
https://tamoxifen.bid/# how to get nolvadex
Abortion pills online http://furosemide.win/# furosemide
generic lasix
buy cytotec cytotec best price cytotec abortion pill
buy cytotec pills https://lipitor.guru/# lipitor 20 mg tablet price
furosemide 40 mg
tamoxifen for gynecomastia reviews: buy tamoxifen citrate – nolvadex pct
lisinopril prescription coupon: buy lisinopril 10 mg tablet – lisinopril 40
cytotec buy online usa https://lipitor.guru/# lipitor generic price canada
furosemide 100 mg
https://tamoxifen.bid/# tamoxifen dosage
order cytotec online: buy cytotec online – Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
tamoxifen effectiveness: nolvadex 20mg – tamoxifen breast cancer
cytotec buy online usa http://lisinopril.guru/# lisinopril medication generic
lasix 40mg
https://cytotec.pro/# buy cytotec online
generic lipitor online: Atorvastatin 20 mg buy online – lipitor purchase
cytotec abortion pill https://tamoxifen.bid/# tamoxifen men
lasix 20 mg
buy cytotec online fast delivery: cheapest cytotec – buy cytotec pills
Cytotec 200mcg price https://tamoxifen.bid/# nolvadex for pct
lasix generic name
tamoxifen hot flashes: Purchase Nolvadex Online – tamoxifen effectiveness
prinivil tabs: buy lisinopril – prescription drug lisinopril
buy benemid without prescription – order tegretol online cheap order generic carbamazepine 200mg
buy cytotec over the counter https://furosemide.win/# lasix 20 mg
furosemida 40 mg
purchase lipitor: buy lipitor 20mg – lipitor generic atorvastatin
buy cytotec over the counter: buy cytotec online fast delivery – п»їcytotec pills online
oral gabapentin 600mg – cost motrin 600mg buy azulfidine pills
buy cytotec pills online cheap https://furosemide.win/# lasix furosemide 40 mg
lasix pills
https://mexstarpharma.online/# best online pharmacies in mexico
mexican drugstore online purple pharmacy mexico price list mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
https://mexstarpharma.online/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://easyrxindia.com/# top 10 pharmacies in india
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa best online pharmacies in mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies
cross border pharmacy canada: canadian pharmacy tampa – cheap canadian pharmacy
india pharmacy mail order: top online pharmacy india – indianpharmacy com
http://easyrxcanada.com/# buying from canadian pharmacies
mexican drugstore online pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://easyrxindia.com/# Online medicine order
reputable mexican pharmacies online: п»їbest mexican online pharmacies – mexico drug stores pharmacies
top 10 online pharmacy in india: india pharmacy – buy prescription drugs from india
https://easyrxcanada.online/# buy drugs from canada
canada drug pharmacy: canada discount pharmacy – canadian drugs
http://easyrxcanada.com/# prescription drugs canada buy online
top online pharmacy india: indian pharmacies safe – india online pharmacy
cheapest online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – pharmacy website india
https://easyrxindia.com/# top 10 online pharmacy in india
sweet bonanza free spin demo: sweet bonanza free spin demo – sweet bonanza yasal site
deneme bonusu veren slot siteleri: slot siteleri guvenilir – en iyi slot siteleri
cost colospa 135mg – where to buy arcoxia without a prescription pletal 100mg tablet
en iyi slot siteleri: slot bahis siteleri – deneme bonusu veren siteler
https://sweetbonanza.network/# sweet bonanza hilesi
deneme bonusu veren siteler: en iyi slot siteleri – slot oyun siteleri
celecoxib us – order urispas pill cheap indomethacin 75mg
https://denemebonusuverensiteler.win/# bahis siteleri
deneme bonusu veren siteler: slot bahis siteleri – yeni slot siteleri
guvenilir slot siteleri 2024: en yeni slot siteleri – slot bahis siteleri
en iyi slot siteler: yasal slot siteleri – canl? slot siteleri
https://slotsiteleri.bid/# guvenilir slot siteleri
https://denemebonusuverensiteler.win/# bonus veren siteler
en guvenilir slot siteleri: slot bahis siteleri – slot oyun siteleri
https://1win.directory/# 1вин сайт
ван вин: 1win – 1win
пин ап вход: pin up – pin up казино
1хбет официальный сайт: 1хбет официальный сайт – 1хбет официальный сайт
https://1win.directory/# 1вин сайт
1win 1вин 1вин зеркало
пин ап вход: pin up casino – pin up casino
pin up: пинап казино – пинап казино
buy rumalaya generic – cost endep buy endep 10mg online cheap
https://1xbet.contact/# 1xbet зеркало
пин ап вход: пин ап вход – пин ап зеркало
pin up casino: пин ап вход – pin up casino
buy voltaren 100mg generic – aspirin uk aspirin 75 mg uk
1win зеркало: 1вин зеркало – 1вин сайт
http://1win.directory/# 1win зеркало
http://pin-up.diy/# пин ап казино вход
пин ап вход: пин ап казино вход – пин ап